What you need to know: Impact of the SVB Closure on the Canadian tech ecosystem
Image generated with text prompts on MidJourney... cool right?
Hey Artemis, what’s with the article on SVB? Aren’t there dozens of these posted every day talking about the same things? (...the author asks himself).
We’ve read through all the latest news on the SVB closure to bring you the Canadian context, highlighting the known and potential implications on our tech ecosystem and beyond.
Immediate Acute Impacts on Canadian Tech Companies
While the SVB collapse is expected to have a low impact on the majority of Canadian companies, it does introduce some immediate challenges for a select group of startups. As the Council of Canadian Innovators (CCI) noted, SVB plays a different role in Canada, providing only venture debt locally without a banking license. This means that Canadian-domiciled companies are less likely to have their funds directly with the bank. According to CCI president Benjamin Bergen, most Canadian startups he spoke with fall under the $250,000 limit that the FDIC is covering as part of its takeover of SVB in the US. However, the shutdown potentially eliminates a pool of capital that Canadian startups have relied on during the downturn, as SVB Canada sources its venture debt lending capital from deposits made outside the country. The closure also affects startups that have their US banking with SVB or Canadian companies legally domiciled in the US for tax purposes and use SVB. Many Canadian startups used SVB for their US bank accounts, as the bank offered more reasonable rates and quicker assistance than Canadian banks operating in the US. In the short term, these startups will need to find alternative banking solutions and navigate the challenges brought on by the sudden loss of SVB's services. The ripple effects of the SVB collapse are being felt by startups that aren't directly affiliated with SVB, as institutions like RBCx face increased workloads from SVB loan takeovers. As a result, staff at these institutions are swamped with handling the fallout from the SVB collapse, leading to postponed meetings and extended timelines for new loans and funding arrangements. This indirect impact on startups underscores the broader implications of the SVB closure, which extends beyond the immediate disruption of banking services to affect the Canadian tech ecosystem as a whole. These startups, too, must adapt to the changing landscape and find ways to secure funding amid the ongoing turbulence. 👉 Implications for Hiring and Tech Talent: The immediate challenges faced by startups that relied on SVB for their banking needs could lead to short-term uncertainty in the tech job market. Companies may have to delay hiring decisions or, in some cases, reconsider their expansion plans. For tech talent, this could mean a temporary slowdown in job opportunities or increased competition for available positions. However, it's worth noting that during the 2008 financial crisis, the tech industry proved to be more resilient than other sectors, and many startups emerged stronger and more agile after the initial turbulence subsided. Therefore, it's possible that the tech sector will rebound in a similar manner following the SVB closure.
Banks Eyeing the Gap Left by SVB
The closure of SVB has created a gap in the market for specialized banking services tailored to the tech sector. As a result, Canadian banks have taken notice of this opportunity and are exploring ways to fill the void left by SVB. Local banks are considering offering specialized financial services to meet the needs of tech companies, which could significantly impact the growth and development of the Canadian tech industry. RBC is one of the banks at the forefront of providing specialized financial services to tech companies. Their RBCx initiative aims to offer venture debt services and growth capital solutions to startups and high-growth companies. An SVB-style banking collapse is less likely to occur in Canada due to the country's strong regulatory framework, which offers a sense of reassurance to tech companies and investors looking to make the transition. “In Canada, I don’t think we’re going to have the same problem, because our banks are so diversified in terms of who their clients are. But in the U.S., I foresee more regulations regarding who their clients are, who are they depositors are, and where they park their money.” (Chayawat Ornthanalai via Toronto Star) 👉 Implications for Hiring and Tech Talent: As Canadian banks explore ways to fill the void left by SVB, tech talent may find more diverse job opportunities within the financial sector. For example, during the dot-com bubble in the early 2000s, financial institutions played a significant role in providing funding and support to tech companies, which resulted in job growth and expanded opportunities for tech professionals. If local banks succeed in catering to the tech sector's unique needs, this could foster a favorable environment for hiring and retaining tech talent, ultimately benefiting the Canadian tech ecosystem.
Tech Industry's Response
Companies are actively engaging with banks, investors, and government representatives to address the challenges posed by the SVB closure and to explore new avenues for growth and support. These collaborative efforts are essential in helping the tech ecosystem adapt and find alternative sources of funding and banking services. In particular, VCs are working closely with their portfolio companies to explore alternative financing options and provide guidance on managing their financial resources during this transition period. Some VCs are also taking this opportunity to advocate for policy changes that could benefit the tech ecosystem, such as tax incentives for investments in startups and improved access to government-backed funding programs. By actively engaging with government representatives and policymakers, VCs are working to ensure that the tech sector receives the support it needs to thrive in the post-SVB era. 👉 Implications for Hiring and Tech Talent: The active collaboration between companies, banks, investors, and government representatives to address the challenges posed by the SVB closure may lead to new support mechanisms for the tech industry. This, in turn, could create a more stable environment for tech companies to grow and hire talent over the long run.
Chilling Effect on Investments
The collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) has raised concerns within Canada's technology sector about a chilling effect on investments. The closure has left many Canadian startups worried about cash flow and their next round of funding. Although the US regulators and Canada's Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions have taken steps to safeguard the financial system and seize SVB's Canadian assets, concerns persist. The already-strained tech investment landscape, exacerbated by consumers shifting back to pre-pandemic habits and rising interest rates, has made it challenging for entrepreneurs to secure funds. Consequently, some have resorted to workforce reductions. Canadian tech companies have received $668.3 million in investments across 38 deals this year, a significant decline from the $14 billion raised across 701 deals in 2021. However, it is essential to acknowledge the resilience and adaptability of the Canadian tech ecosystem. This challenging period may present new opportunities for startups to explore alternative funding sources, forge new partnerships, and develop innovative business models. Additionally, the Canadian government and private sector may step up to provide support and resources to local startups, further strengthening the tech ecosystem. In the long run, overcoming these obstacles could lead to a more robust and self-reliant Canadian tech sector, better equipped to weather future challenges and maintain its global competitiveness. 👉 Implications for Hiring and Tech Talent: The potential chilling effect on investments could result in a tighter labor market for tech professionals, similar to what happened during the 2008 financial crisis and the dot-com bubble burst. In the short term, startups may prioritize conserving resources and might be hesitant to expand their workforce. This could lead to increased competition for available jobs and a heightened reliance on startups securing funding to retain and attract top talent. However, as companies explore alternative funding sources and the tech ecosystem adapts to the new landscape, the long-term prospects for hiring and tech talent may improve.
Impact on Mortgage Rates & Wider Economic Implications
The SVB closure has also affected the broader financial landscape in Canada, including a surprising decline in mortgage interest rates across the country. Due to the shock move in the Treasury market following the SVB collapse, the lowered rates have come as a relief for the housing market. While the SVB closure has led to a decline in mortgage interest rates, it remains to be seen whether this will have an effect on the Bank of Canada's interest rates. However, it is important to note that the central bank's decision will be influenced by a wide array of factors, such as inflation, economic growth, and employment metrics. As financial markets adjust to the collapse, stakeholders should pay close attention to the central bank's policy decisions and continue to monitor the evolving situation. In the United States, the Federal Reserve has recently announced a 25 basis-point rate hike, signaling potential changes in the global monetary environment. Canadian market participants will need to closely observe the Bank of Canada's response to these developments to gauge the potential impact on the country's interest rate policies and overall financial climate. 👉 Implications for Hiring and Tech Talent: Though mortgage rate changes may not have a direct impact on tech talent, the broader economic implications of the SVB closure could affect the overall job market and financial stability. Similar to the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, tech professionals should remain vigilant and consider how the evolving economic climate might influence their career choices and financial planning. A more stable economy could contribute to a healthier job market and increased opportunities for tech talent.
CDIC working towards further stabilizing business banking system in Canada
The SVB collapse has raised concerns about the adequacy of the current deposit insurance coverage in Canada, which stands at a maximum of CAD 100,000 per depositor per insured institution. This coverage limit, set by the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation (CDIC), has not been updated since 2005, sparking debates on whether it still meets the needs of Canadian depositors in the face of a rapidly changing economic landscape. Policymakers and financial experts are considering several options, including raising the coverage limit and introducing a tiered system, which would provide varying levels of protection depending on the type of account and depositor. In the long term, a potential increase in deposit insurance limits or the implementation of a tiered system could prove beneficial for Canadian startups and businesses. Enhanced deposit insurance coverage would likely bolster confidence in the stability of the financial system, encouraging businesses to maintain or even increase their cash reserves within insured institutions. This could lead to increased liquidity for startups, enabling them to better withstand economic fluctuations and unexpected expenses. In addition, a more robust deposit insurance framework would create a more secure environment for businesses to access capital and pursue growth opportunities. Increased trust in the financial system could attract foreign investors, fostering a favorable climate for startups and small businesses to thrive.
Key takeaways for hiring and tech talent
The SVB closure and subsequent investor hesitancy could have significant short-term implications for innovation and talent in the Canadian tech industry, a sector already grappling with the need for increased VC capital deployment. As the industry faces uncertainty, the talent market is expected to experience a shift, marked by intensified competition for available jobs and a heightened reliance on startups to secure funding in order to retain and attract top talent.
This challenging environment may prompt job-seekers to pursue more stable opportunities in established tech companies or even consider pivoting to other industries altogether. The decreased availability of funding may also compel startups to reevaluate their hiring strategies, focusing on critical roles while deprioritizing others, which could, in turn, impact overall job growth within the Canadian tech ecosystem.
Furthermore, the decline in available funding may have a dampening effect on innovation, as startups may be forced to scale back their ambitions and focus on short-term survival rather than long-term growth and disruptive advancements. This could result in a slower pace of technological breakthroughs, potentially affecting Canada's global competitiveness in the tech sector. Ultimately, the SVB closure serves as a reminder of the importance of a stable and diverse financial landscape in supporting a thriving tech industry and fostering innovation.
The Canadian tech ecosystem is at a critical juncture, and fostering a supportive environment for growth and innovation will be essential to ensuring its continued success. By leveraging the strengths of local financial institutions, encouraging government support, and maintaining a proactive stance within the tech industry, Canada has the potential to emerge from this challenge stronger and more resilient than ever.
Subscribe to our monthly Artemis Update to receive future Salary Snapshots directly to your inbox + more great content including our Industry Insights, Leaders on the Move, Humans of Tech, Dear Artemis and Tech Women on the Move series.
Artemis Canada is a boutique executive search firm specializing in placing top talent in the tech sector across Canada, the United States, and Europe. Our team of experienced recruiters has a proven track record of finding exceptional candidates for a variety of roles, from C-suite positions to high-demand individual contributors. For more information on our services, please visit our website at https://www.artemiscanada.com/